Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

This article on Cracked nearly completely ruins its point from the start with an Alzheimer's joke (wtf?!), yet despite that screw-up, it makes a very compelling case for Glinda the Good Witch being Glinda the Evil Mastermind in the original Wizard of Oz movie.

  • Glinda breezes in to ask Dorothy if she's a good witch or a bad witch, since only a witch would've had the power to off the Witch of the East— but wait,  D. has no magic, so just whose magic was steering that house, anyway? HMMM?
  • Glinda helps make sure it's known by all and sundry that Dorothy Did It. She especially makes sure that the Witch of the West believes this.
  • Glinda mockingly uses magic to despoil the corpse and superglue the WotE's ruby slippers to Dorothy's feet right under the nose of the Witch of the West, who is next of kin. This is fair? 
  • Glinda taunts the WotW that she can't harm Dorothy in Munchkinland because REASONS.
  • After goading the WotW into an impotent rage, Glinda instructs Dorothy to leave Munchkinland, the one place where the WotW can't harm her, to seek out the Wizard of Oz, who will be able to send her back to Kansas FOR REELZ.
  • So Dorothy is sent out on a quest where, sooner or later, the WotW will catch her, and then it will be To the Death for one of them. (But the ruby slippers, Glinda says, grant some protection to Dorothy, so WotW is the more likely victim). 
  • Surprise! The Wizard of Oz's price for help is that Dorothy must kill the WotW. (Well, really, to steal her broom, but as the Scarecrow says, the only way is to kill her.) Suspicion: Glinda is pulling the wizard's strings, too.
  • So, after Dorothy has pulled off the assassination, it turns out that Glinda lied; the wizard can't really send Dorothy back.
  • Glinda says, "Ha ha, actually, you didn't need to go on this hero quest at all; you just needed to tap your heels to go straight home." Which she knew all along, but said she didn't tell Dorothy because "she wouldn't have believed me."
  • So now the other witches are dead, the wizard is discredited and flees the country, and Glinda has the reins of power! All shall love her and despair! Bwaahahaha! (And I suppose we hear nothing of the Witch of the South because she has wisely gone into hiding.) 
I still like Tin Man's take on Oz better than any other (and I should watch it again... loved Zooey Dewhatsit in that before she became a star, go me). But I also like the above interpretation, since we all sensed even when we were kids that Glinda's beautiful:good::ugly:evil BS was a pile of carp. 
This entry was originally posted at http://auronlu.dreamwidth.org/222326.html, where it has comment count unavailablecomments.




( 5 comments — Leave a comment )
Feb. 18th, 2013 05:28 am (UTC)


Mind blown. Should have picked up on all of this long before now.
Feb. 18th, 2013 10:02 am (UTC)
Yes, this definiitely ties in with what you were saying about the queen in Snow White. I'm not quite sure how, but it does.

Also, some kind of lesson about how grown ups will tell you it was only a dream, and won't believe you when you tell the truth, whereas they will lie to you on the presumption that you won't believe them.

Edited at 2013-02-18 10:03 am (UTC)
Feb. 18th, 2013 10:00 pm (UTC)
Cracked humor is frequently in VERY poor taste but that is a good article. I would really love to see some kind of reboot from this perspective. :D

I remember as a child feeling so betrayed when it turns out that the Wizard is a fraud and can't send Dorothy home again and that she had the power all along but nobody had told her. It wasn't until I was an adult watching it again though that I really noticed how much Dorothy is being manipulated by all the adults in power.

And I loved Tin Man! I've liked Zooey since back then too but I can't tell anyone because all my friends are haters. :/
Feb. 18th, 2013 11:03 pm (UTC)
I actually stayed up last night very late writing a letter from the Witch of the North to Dorothy, sending her some kind of heirloom to keep it out of Glinda's hands before she destroys her last rival.

It clinched it for me when I did a little Wikipedia surfing this morning and rediscovered that Glinda is actually the Witch of the South in the books, and the Witch of the North was taken out of the movie entirely with her role given to Glinda. Movieverse thus makes Glinda a usurper. :)

And gosh, who could hate Zooey? I haven't followed her recent work, as I'm not into fictionalizations of real life -- I want fantasy, dangit; I can read the news if I want that -- but she was smart, funny, and had a great delivery, as well as being cute without being a wimp. What more could one ask for?

Edited at 2013-02-18 11:04 pm (UTC)
Feb. 19th, 2013 12:07 am (UTC)
Your logic - sense it makes. ^_^ Yeah, I had that vibe, even as a kid, when I saw the movie and Glinda's smarm made my teeth ache.
( 5 comments — Leave a comment )
Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by Lilia Ahner